Burns Puppy Food: Chicken & Rice or Lamb?
PawPicked is reader-supported: we may earn a commission from links on this page.
Both of these are 12kg bags of Burns Original puppy food, so the choice comes down to the protein and to how much you can verify before you buy. The listings are uneven: the lamb one shows a full ingredient panel and nutrient table, while the chicken one shows neither in the text available to us. That difference matters more than the flavour.
| Chicken & Rice | Lamb | |
|---|---|---|
| Bag | 12kg | 12kg |
| Listing rating | 4.6 out of 5 from 1,097 ratings | 4.3 out of 5 from 39 ratings |
| Ingredient panel on listing | Not shown | White rice 18%, brown rice 17%, lamb meal 16%, then rice protein, oats, lamb fat, peas, pea protein, salmon oil, seaweed, minerals |
| Analytical figures | Not shown | Protein 24%, fat 15%, fibre 3.3%, ash 7%, calcium 1.6%, phosphorus 1.2% |
| Prebiotic | Chicory extract | Not mentioned |
| Omega fatty acids | Not shown | Omega-6 2.1%, omega-3 0.5% |
| Directions on listing | "A handful per day" | Use within 3 months once opened |
What the listings show
Burns Original Puppy Chicken & Rice is described as a complete food with vitamins A, D3 and E and chicory extract as a natural prebiotic. The listing says it has controlled protein and fat to support brain development and steady growth, and claims this reduces the risk of later skeletal issues. That is the maker's claim, and the listing gives no figures to back it up. It has a strong rating by volume: 1,097 ratings is a good-sized sample.
Burns Original Puppy Lamb has the opposite profile. The panel is shown in full, with lamb meal at 16% and a mix of white and brown rice at 18% and 17%. Salmon oil, seaweed and the omega-3 and omega-6 figures are listed, along with a table of added vitamins and trace elements. The bullets claim support for healthy growth, skin and coat and low daily feeding costs. It rates lower, at 4.3 out of 5, but from only 39 ratings, so the gap says little.
Differences that matter
Transparency. With the lamb you can see the panel and the numbers. With the chicken you cannot, so you would be relying on the bag. Neither is a reason to avoid it, but if you like to check before buying, the lamb listing is easier to assess.
Calcium. The lamb listing shows calcium at 1.6% and phosphorus at 1.2%. Large and giant breed owners often check these figures with a vet, because mineral levels matter for big puppies, and Burns lists the puppy range with confusing size fields. The chicken listing says both small and large breeds, the lamb listing says small breeds twice. We would not assume either is a large-breed food. Ask your vet, or ask the maker, if your puppy will be big.
Ratings. The two scores are not directly comparable. The chicken recipe's 4.6 comes from over a thousand ratings, while the lamb's 4.3 rests on 39, where a handful of unhappy reviews can move the average. Neither score tells you how your puppy will do on it, and ratings on Amazon often mix comments on delivery, packaging and price with comments on the food.
Feeding directions. "Serve a handful per day" on the chicken listing is not a measurement, and a handful varies between hands. Use the feeding table on the bag, weigh the portion, and adjust for body condition. The lamb listing gives no daily amount in the text we have, but does say to use the bag within 3 months once opened, which is worth noting for a 12kg bag.
Allergies and sensitivities
If you are choosing between these because a dog seems to react to one protein, be careful. A listing showing a lamb meal does not mean the recipe is free from other meats, and the lamb one includes salmon oil and several plant proteins, including rice protein and pea protein. We cannot see the chicken panel at all. Swapping from chicken to lamb is therefore not a test of an allergy. If you suspect a food allergy, a vet-led elimination diet is the reliable route, and our guide to hypoallergenic dog food explains why. If you do want to try the lamb, read the ingredients on the actual bag, and ask the maker about cross-contact with other proteins.
Changing between them
If you move a puppy from one to the other, do it gradually. Mix the two over a week or so, as set out in how to switch your dog's food. The same applies when you eventually move up to adult food, which this guide to the timing covers.
Choose chicken or lamb
Choose the chicken and rice if you want the better-supported rating, a prebiotic in the recipe, and you are happy to read the bag for the ingredient and nutrient detail. Choose the lamb if you want to see the panel and the nutrient figures before you buy, or if you want a different protein from a chicken-based diet your puppy already eats, and you accept the lower number of ratings. For either, confirm with your vet that the size band suits your breed. Our wider comparison in best puppy dry food in the UK sets the chicken recipe against four other brands.
Products in this article
Affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.