Burns vs James Wellbeloved: Two Hypoallergenic Staples Compared
PawPicked is reader-supported: we may earn a commission from links on this page.
Start with the first line of each ingredients list, because that is where these two foods part ways. Burns Original Adult & Senior Chicken & Brown Rice lists brown rice at 67% and dried chicken at 20%. James Wellbeloved Adult Hypoallergenic Turkey & Rice lists dried turkey protein at 24% and then splits its carbohydrate across several grains. Both are marketed as hypoallergenic everyday dry foods, and both are long-standing names in the sensitive-dog aisle, but they are built differently.
The numbers from the listings
| Burns Original | James Wellbeloved Turkey & Rice | |
|---|---|---|
| Bag size | 6kg | 7.5kg |
| Main protein | Dried chicken (20%) | Dried turkey protein (24%) |
| Main carbohydrate | Brown rice (67%), oats, peas | Naked oats, brown rice (13%), white rice (13%), barley |
| Other listed items | Chicken oil, sunflower oil, seaweed (0.5%), minerals | Linseed (3.9%), poultry fat, sugar beet pulp, turkey gravy, alfalfa, pea fibre, seaweed (0.5%), fish oil, chicory, yucca |
| Stated exclusions | None listed | Beef, pork, soya, eggs, dairy, wheat |
| Feeding guidance on listing | 400 to 600g per day | Guidelines only; reduce dry by 25g per 100g of wet if mixing |
| Amazon rating | 4.6 out of 5 from 2,883 ratings | 4.7 out of 5 from 238 ratings |
Protein and grain, in plain terms
Burns is the simpler recipe. A single named protein, a single dominant grain and a short list of extras. Because brown rice makes up most of the food by weight, it is a high-carbohydrate recipe with a modest meat content, and that is by design: limited ingredients and an easily digested base is the idea behind many sensitive-stomach diets. The listing also describes it as hypoallergenic, single-source protein, and veterinary-developed. Those are the maker's descriptions.
James Wellbeloved has more going on. It has the higher stated meat content, but the carbohydrate is spread across naked oats, brown rice, white rice and barley, and there is linseed, sugar beet pulp, fish oil and a handful of botanicals as well. The listing's headline claim is the exclusion list: no beef, pork, soya, eggs, dairy or wheat. That is useful if your dog's trigger is on that list, and the Burns listing does not make an equivalent statement. The James Wellbeloved bullets add "no added artificial colours, flavours or antioxidants"; the Burns Original bullets do not make that statement, though that is not the same as saying it contains them.
Neither is grain-free, and neither claims to be. Dogs that do well on one grain-inclusive food often do well on another, but a dog with a problem specifically with cereals will need to look elsewhere; grain-free or grain-inclusive weighs up that choice. Note too that both are poultry-based, chicken in one and turkey in the other. A dog with a poultry sensitivity may react to either, and James Wellbeloved also lists poultry fat.
What the label cannot promise
"Hypoallergenic" is a marketing word, not a regulated standard, and both listings use it. It means the recipe was designed to avoid some common triggers, not that your dog will not react. Hypoallergenic dog food in the UK, explained goes through what the term does and does not cover. If your dog has a diagnosed allergy, a vet-led plan comes first. This article is general information, not veterinary advice.
Feeding notes worth knowing
The two listings give different practical guidance. Burns says to keep the food dry and serve 400 to 600g a day, which is a broad range, so your dog's weight, age and activity will decide where in it you land. James Wellbeloved says that if you mix its dry food with its wet food you should reduce the dry portion by 25g for every 100g of wet, that treat calories should be counted, and that the amounts are guidelines to adjust for age, size and activity. That is the more careful of the two instructions, and it is a useful habit with either food: weigh the portions and watch the dog's waistline rather than the scoop.
Weak points on each side
For Burns: the listing's feeding range is wide at 400 to 600g a day and does not tie amounts to dog weight, percentages are given for only the first few ingredients, and the main carbohydrate is a lot of rice. The listing also contains some marketing copy about packaging transitions that tells you nothing about the food.
For James Wellbeloved: the larger bag is more to commit to, the recipe includes barley and fish oil, which some dogs avoid, and the listing's feeding information is only general guidance. The listing's size fields are inconsistent, so rely on the pack for what suits your dog.
On the ratings, Burns has far more behind its 4.6 than James Wellbeloved has behind its 4.7, though neither figure tells you whether the food will suit your dog.
Choosing between them
Choose Burns Original if you want a plain, rice-led recipe with a single named meat, a smaller bag to try first and a food that is fully described on the listing down to the percentages of its top ingredients. It suits a dog with a generally touchy digestion that copes with chicken.
Choose James Wellbeloved Turkey & Rice if your dog needs to avoid beef, pork, soya, eggs, dairy or wheat, you would rather have turkey than chicken and you do not mind a larger bag. Do read the full pack label either way.
For the full detail on each, there is our Burns Original review and our James Wellbeloved review. If you change foods, do it gradually, over a week or more.
Products in this article
Affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.