Best Value Puppy Food in the UK Without Cutting Corners
PawPicked is reader-supported: we may earn a commission from links on this page.
Value in puppy food is not the same as the lowest price on the shelf. A cheap bag that your puppy will not eat, or that you cannot store properly, costs more than it looks. For this roundup we looked only at large-format puppy foods from two UK-linked brands and judged them on four things the listings let us check: whether the food says it is complete, how much of the recipe is disclosed, whether the pack is a size a household can realistically finish, and whether the listing contradicts itself.
We have not quoted prices, because they move. Instead, the sections below end with a method you can use yourself.
Harringtons Complete Puppy Turkey & Rice: best all-rounder on the information given
Harringtons Complete Puppy Turkey & Rice comes in an 18kg bag. It is the most fully described of the three. The listing gives the ingredients with percentages (turkey and meat meals 33%, oats 15.5%, rice 5.6%, chicken fat 5%), an analysis of 30% protein and 14% fat, and an energy figure of 383kcal per 100g. It describes smaller kibbles meant for small mouths, and says it is suitable for all breed sizes.
Amazon.co.uk shows 4.6 out of 5 from 5,169 ratings at the time of writing, by far the largest sample of the three.
The main drawback is the bag itself. At 18kg, it is a lot of kibble for a toy or small breed puppy that will outgrow the recipe before finishing it. It also contains maize, oats and a "wheat may contain" allergen note, so it is not for owners who need to avoid grain. The listing's turkey content is also modest at 7% dried turkey inside a 33% meat meal category.
Harringtons Superfoods Puppy Chicken & Veg: best for those who want grain-free
Harringtons Superfoods Puppy Chicken & Veg is a 10kg grain-free recipe. The listing states 35% chicken (including 26% dried chicken and 5% chicken fat) with sweet potato at 26%, plus potato, peas and beans. It says there is no grain, wheat, dairy or soya. The botanical blend (rosemary, spinach, pomegranate and blueberries) is only 1500mg/kg, which is worth keeping in mind next to the word "superfood".
It has 4.7 out of 5 from 241 ratings at the time of writing, so the sample is much smaller. The 10kg bag is more manageable than the 18kg one for many homes.
The drawbacks: the text we have includes no analysis or energy figure, the listing is crowded with broad health claims we have not repeated, and it does not say "complete" in the text provided, so check the pack for that wording before buying. The carbohydrate base is potato and legumes, which some owners prefer to avoid. If you are unsure whether grain-free is worth it, our explainer on grain-free versus grain-inclusive food helps. For a closer comparison of the two Harringtons recipes, see Turkey & Rice versus Superfoods.
Burns Original Puppy Chicken & Rice: best if you want a vet-developed brand, with a disclosure gap
Burns Original Puppy Chicken & Rice is a 12kg bag. The listing says it is 100% complete, with vitamins A, D3 and E, chicory extract as a natural prebiotic, and seaweed, and that it has controlled protein and fat for steady growth. It also says it was developed by a veterinary surgeon, John Burns. That is the maker's story and not an independent endorsement.
Amazon.co.uk shows 4.6 out of 5 from 1,097 ratings at the time of writing.
The drawback is disclosure. The text we have does not include an ingredient list, analysis or energy figure, so you cannot compare it against the others on paper. The listing's breed fields also disagree: one says small breeds and another says large. We would not trust either, and would check the pack and, if in doubt, contact the maker. The feeding instruction on the listing is a single vague line, so you will want the pack's table. If you are weighing it against a lamb version of the same food, see Burns chicken or lamb.
How to work out cost per day
Pack price on its own tells you very little. The method is simple.
- Find the daily amount for your puppy's age and expected adult weight in the feeding guide on the pack.
- Divide the bag weight in grams by that daily amount to estimate how many days it lasts. This changes as your puppy grows, so recalculate every few weeks.
- Divide the pack price by the number of days. Check the current price on Amazon at the time of buying.
Do the same for each food you are comparing. A food with a higher daily feeding amount can cost more per day even if the bag looks cheaper, and a more energy-dense recipe may need less food. Remember to count treats and training rewards in the daily total.
Keeping a big bag fresh
Large bags save money only if the last of the food is still good. Most makers advise storing kibble in a cool, dry place and using it before the best-before date, and Harringtons says exactly that on the Superfoods listing. Many owners tip the food into an airtight container, keeping the original bag inside it so the batch number and date stay to hand. Try to avoid warm spots such as next to a boiler or in a sunny utility room. If you are not confident of finishing 18kg in a reasonable time after opening, a smaller bag is the better value, whatever the per-kilo figure suggests.
Whichever food you choose, switch to it slowly, mixing it in with the old food over several days rather than changing overnight.
When none of these suit
If your puppy is a giant breed, needs a particular protein, or has a diagnosed sensitivity, a value pick may not be the right place to start. In those cases, ask your vet before choosing, or see our wider puppy dry food comparison.
For most healthy puppies of an average breed, the practical route is to choose a food that says it is complete, discloses what is in it, comes in a bag you can finish, and that your puppy actually eats.
Products in this article
Affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.