Burns Sensitive: Duck & Brown Rice or Chicken?
PawPicked is reader-supported: we may earn a commission from links on this page.
Choosing between Burns Sensitive Duck & Brown Rice and Burns Sensitive Chicken is really a choice about protein, and about which proteins your dog has already met. Both come in a 6kg bag, both are described as complete foods for adult and senior dogs with sensitive skin or digestion, and both carry the Burns "hypoallergenic" label. The recipes underneath differ more than the packaging suggests.
The two listings side by side
| Duck & Brown Rice | Chicken | |
|---|---|---|
| Pack | 6kg | 6kg |
| Ingredients as listed | Brown rice, duck, sunflower oil, oats (listing lists "seaweek", presumably seaweed) | Wholegrain maize, chicken meal, peas, chicken oil, seaweed, minerals |
| Main protein | Duck | Chicken meal |
| Listing features | Novel protein source (duck), limited ingredient | Hypoallergenic, developed by a veterinary surgeon |
| Percentages given | None | None |
| Feeding guidance shown | Storage and moistening advice only | About 100g per meal |
| Amazon rating | 4.6 out of 5 from 1,135 ratings | 4.6 out of 5 from 257 ratings |
The ingredient fields in both listings are marketing-style summaries rather than full declarations, so neither gives percentages, and the order may not reflect the true composition. Check the pack for the full legal list.
What actually differs
The carbohydrate source is the clearest split. The duck recipe is built on brown rice and oats; the chicken recipe uses wholegrain maize and peas. Neither is grain-free. For a dog that has reacted to maize, the duck version may be worth considering; for a dog that handles cereals fine, this matters less.
The protein is the other split. Duck is described as a "novel protein", which only means something if your dog has not eaten it before. A protein is novel to the dog, not to the food industry, so a dog that has had duck treats or duck-based food in the past has no novelty advantage here. Chicken, on the other hand, is among the proteins most often mentioned in dog food allergy discussions, largely because it is so widely used. That is not a reason to avoid it for a dog that has eaten it happily for years, but it explains why vets often suggest a different protein when they suspect a food reaction.
The duck listing also gives specific uses of "food allergies, skin and coat health, stomach". The chicken listing stops at skin and coat and digestion. Treat those as marketing summaries rather than evidence.
The chicken recipe includes chicken meal and chicken oil, so the chicken is present in more than one form. The duck listing is simpler in that respect. The listings also disagree on a detail: the duck one says it suits "medium breeds" in one field and "all breeds" in another, so if size matters to you, check the pack before assuming.
Why you shouldn't swap proteins mid-trial
If a vet has put your dog on an elimination diet, the whole point is to feed one carefully chosen diet and nothing else for several weeks, often around eight to twelve, though your vet will say. Swapping from chicken to duck, or the other way round, partway through resets the clock and makes it impossible to tell what is helping. The same goes for treats, flavoured medicines and table scraps, which can undo weeks of work with a single biscuit.
If you are choosing a food yourself rather than following a vet's plan, the same logic applies in a softer form. Pick one, feed it consistently for a sensible stretch and judge the result, rather than rotating between bags every fortnight. How to switch your dog's food covers the changeover itself, and what hypoallergenic does and doesn't mean explains why that word on the front of the bag is not a guarantee. This article is general information, not veterinary advice, and a dog with ongoing skin or stomach problems should be seen by a vet.
Downsides of both
- Neither listing shows ingredient percentages, so you cannot see how much duck or chicken the recipe contains.
- Both contain cereals, which will not suit dogs that need a grain-free diet.
- The "hypoallergenic" label is a marketing term, not a guarantee that a food is free from anything that affects your dog.
- The duck listing gives no feeding amount, so you will need the pack.
If you want to see how Burns compares with another long-standing sensitive-diet brand, Burns against James Wellbeloved does that, and Royal Canin Sensitivity Control against Burns Sensitive adds the vet-diet angle.
Which to choose
Choose Burns Sensitive Duck & Brown Rice if your dog has eaten chicken for most of its life, if chicken is a suspect, or if you want a simple cereal base of rice and oats rather than maize. It has the larger number of ratings, but the listing offers no feeding guide.
Choose Burns Sensitive Chicken if your dog does well on chicken, you want a feeding amount on the page and you are happy with maize and peas in the mix. It suits a dog that simply has a sensitive stomach rather than a suspected protein allergy.
If your dog's reaction has been confirmed or is severe, neither bag is a substitute for a vet-led diet.
Products in this article
Affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.