James Wellbeloved Grain-Free Turkey or Turkey & Rice?
PawPicked is reader-supported: we may earn a commission from links on this page.
James Wellbeloved makes two adult turkey recipes that look almost identical on a supermarket shelf: Adult Grain-Free Turkey and Adult Hypoallergenic Turkey & Rice. Both claim to leave out beef, pork, soya, eggs, dairy and wheat. The difference is what replaces the grain, and that matters more than the label suggests.
What changes between the bags
| Grain-Free Turkey | Turkey & Rice | |
|---|---|---|
| Pack size on the listing | 10 kg | 7.5 kg |
| Dried turkey protein | 24.5% | 24% |
| Main carbohydrate | Pea starch, dried potatoes (24.4%) | Naked oats, brown rice (13%), white rice (13%), barley |
| Pea ingredients listed | Pea starch, dried peas, pea protein, pea fibre | Pea fibre only |
| Linseed | 3.1% | 3.9% |
| Fish oil | Yes | Yes |
| Amazon.co.uk rating | 4.8 out of 5 from 92 ratings | 4.7 out of 5 from 238 ratings |
The turkey content is almost the same, and the fish oil, seaweed, chicory and yucca extract also appear in both. So the real swap is cereal grains and rice on one side against potato and peas on the other.
What the two share
Both listings promise the same basics: carefully selected natural ingredients, natural prebiotics and fibres for digestion, and vitamin E and minerals to support the immune system. These are the maker's claims, offered without trial results, so treat them as a description of the recipe's intent. Both are also adult recipes. If you are weighing them for a puppy or a very old dog, the listings do not say either is suitable, so check the packaging.
Grain-free is a choice, not an upgrade
Grain-free food suits dogs that have a genuine reason to avoid grain, and a vet can sometimes narrow that down. Most dogs, though, are not allergic to rice or oats. Reactions in dogs are more often linked to animal proteins such as beef, dairy, chicken or wheat. If your dog has no diagnosed problem with grain, there is no strong case on the listings for paying attention to the grain-free label alone. Our grain-free versus grain-inclusive comparison goes through the reasoning.
There is a second reason for caution. Some research has examined a possible connection between diets that are both grain-free and heavy in peas, lentils or potatoes and a heart condition in dogs. The evidence is unsettled, and the link has not been shown to apply to any one brand. The grain-free James Wellbeloved recipe is built on pea starch, potatoes and several other pea ingredients, so it is a fair thing to mention to a vet before committing to a 10 kg bag, particularly for a breed prone to heart disease.
The Turkey & Rice listing calls its recipe hypoallergenic, and the grain-free listing carries the same word in its title. That word is a marketing description rather than a regulated standard, which our explainer on what hypoallergenic means on a UK label covers. What the listings do give you is a plain list of what is left out: no beef, pork, soya, eggs, dairy or wheat.
Drawbacks worth knowing about
- Turkey & Rice contains barley and oats. Barley contains gluten, so this is not a food for a dog a vet has told you to keep off gluten.
- The grain-free recipe depends heavily on peas and potato, which is the pattern the heart research above is concerned with.
- Both bags are 7.5 kg or more, so a dog that dislikes the taste leaves you with a lot of unwanted food. Look for a smaller trial pack first if one is available.
- Neither listing gives calorie figures, so the feeding guide on the bag is the only route to cost per day. Divide the pack price by the days it lasts for your dog's weight, and compare that number for the two recipes.
- The grain-free listing has far fewer ratings (92) than the rice one (238), so the star scores are not equally reliable.
When a vet might steer you one way
A vet may suggest a limited-ingredient diet as part of working out whether a food ingredient is behind itching, loose stools or chronic ear trouble. If so, they will usually want one protein, no extras and no treats for several weeks. Neither of these bags is automatically the right tool for that job, because both contain turkey, poultry fat and fish oil. Follow your vet's plan rather than choosing from the label.
If your dog has an unrelated heart or kidney condition, ask which of the two, if either, is appropriate. This article is general information and is not a substitute for veterinary advice.
Changing over
Whichever you pick, move over gradually. Many owners mix a small amount of the new food into the old and shift the proportion across a week to ten days, longer for a dog with a sensitive stomach. Our guide to switching your dog's food has a practical schedule.
Which to buy
Choose the Turkey & Rice if your dog tolerates grain, you would like the more established, more widely rated recipe, and you prefer a smaller bag. A dog that has not been diagnosed with a grain problem has little to gain from skipping rice.
Choose the Grain-Free Turkey if a vet has advised leaving grain out, your dog does well on potato and peas, and you are comfortable with a pea-heavy ingredient list. If you are unsure about the heart question, speak to your vet before buying.
Check the pack size on the listing before ordering, as Amazon sometimes changes which sizes are offered.
Products in this article
Affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.